IWSG Writing Prompt: Do you Choose your Genre in Advance?

Do you choose your genre in advance?

IWSG Writing Prompt: Have you ever written a piece that became a form, or even a genre, you hadn’t planned on writing in? Or do you choose a form/genre in advance?


I traveled to Cambodia for three month doing a mix of travel and volunteering at a bakery. (You can read about it on my personal travel blog Roving Jay).


Workaway around Cambodia
A sampling of my blog posts about our trip to Cambodia

Before I go on a trip I always do a lot of research, so I was able to incorporate some of this content into my first draft, and get my book off to a flying start. It’s always good to overcome those first few blank pages, and I felt good with the direction my book was taking.

I’d decided that I wanted to write a traditional destination travel guide. The plan was to only include destinations we’ve visited, and to include how we got from A to B. When it comes to travel guides, it’s important to narrow your theme and angle to define to content niche before you get too far into your first draft. There are plenty of generic guide books on the market that cover Cambodia, but none are aimed at backpacking baby boomers, so I decided to narrow the target audience to travelers just like me—who want a mature backpacking experience, but also want a few creature comforts.

I took notes copious notes during our trip and thousands of photographs, and worked on my travel guide for a few months before realizing that I found it a bit dry and lacking depth.

Cambodia was my first backpacking trip in over 20 years, and the first extended trip I’d taken with my husband since abandoning our corporate careers and becoming digital nomads. So I started peppering my travel guide with travel anecdotes about being mature backpackers, and also a married couple going on our first backpacking adventure.

By their very nature anecdotes are short, and are usually capped off at the two paragraph mark, but some of my travel recollections were becoming detailed dives into our experiences and reactions to them, and couldn’t really be called anecdotes any more.

For a brief period I contemplated creating two separate books: a Cambodia travel guide, and a Cambodia travel memoir. But instead I settled on creating a hybrid travel guide and travel memoir. By this times I’d created all of my travel guide content, and now I’m working on the anecdote and memoir sections, and working out how to combine these two different genres seamlessly together.

For all of my other nonfiction books I chose my genre, theme, and angle before I started writing, and I usually fine-tune adjustments to the theme and angle as I write so the direction becomes clearer, but this Cambodia travel guide is the only book where I’ve changed the book’s genre, and because it wasn’t a complete about-turn I think the decision is sound.

When you're writing your books, do you choose a form or genre in advance? I usually do, except for my latest Cambodia travel guide, which has become a hybrid guide and memoir. @TheIWSG #IWSG Click To Tweet

UPDATE: It’s November 1st and I’m using this month to participate in a 30 day writing sprint to write the Cambodia Memoir sections of my Cambodia Travel Guide.


About IWSG?

Each first Wednesday of the month, the Insecure Writer’s Support Group (IWSG) encourages writers to talk about your doubts and celebrate your success. Then your task is to visit other blogs on the hop and leave a comment, which will be reciprocated. 

To Sign up to the Hop: Click here

Author: Jay Artale

Focused on helping travel bloggers and writers achieve their self-publishing goals. Owner of Birds of a Feather Press. Travel Writer. Nonfiction Author. Project Manager Specialising in Content Marketing and Social Media Strategy.

4 thoughts on “IWSG Writing Prompt: Do you Choose your Genre in Advance?

  1. Hi, Jay! I loved your idea about combining a travel guide with a travel memoir. That would certainly appeal to me. My husband usually plans our trips. I like to visit a country for the first time without a lot of preconceptions. I take it all in and read the travel guides after I’ve been somewhere. Cambodia ~ I spent four magical days there, and I long to go back. What an amazing country! I told my husband, “Just get me to Angkor Wat”. I will definitely return to read to read about your adventures there.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

CommentLuv badge